duties in cases of need,” the 89th of the minor parvans of
Mhbhr.; cf. Āpaddharma). § 642: Yudhiṣṭhira enquired
of Bhīṣma what should be done by a weak and timid king,
as also by one that is in great distress. Bhīṣma's answer
recommending peace and even the surrender of territory.
The king should never surrender his person as long as he
can avoid doing so. If the invading enemy be righteous, the
assailed king should make peace; if otherwise, the assailed
should fight bravely and fall (XII, 131). How a brahman
should subsist in times of calamity. Bhīṣma began his
exposition of the moral standard of unlucky times; in times
of calamity the king may take from the wicked and give it
to the good; at such times censurable acts do not become
censurable; the king should never oppress brahmans, even
at such times. Slander should be avoided. The tests
of righteousness; difficulty in finding the course of duty.
“Some regard ancient usage as the highest test of
righteousness; they that are in favour of the conduct of
Caṅkha towards Likhita do not hold this opinion” (XII,
132). How a king should fill his treasury. The king
should establish laws which he should never transgress
(XII, 133). The two duties of a kṣattriya are the
acquisition of religious merit and of wealth. The advantages
of Power (XII, 134).—§ 643: The old story of a robber
who having in this world been observant of restraint did
not meet with destruction in the next: Kāyavya-carita (b)
(XII, 135).—§ 644: What wealth should not be taken by
the king (XII, 136).—§ 645: Who enjoy happiness:
Śākulopākhyāna (b) (XII, 137).—§ 646. How a king
should behave who is weak and threatened on all sides by
powerful foes: the old story of the mouse, the cat, the owl,
the mongoose, and the hunter, i.e. Mārjāra-mūṣika-
saṃvāda (b). The moral of the story (XII, 138).—§ 647:
Bhīṣma related the conversation between the bird Pūjanī
and king Brahmadatta, i.e. Brahmadatta-Pūjanī-saṃvāda
(b) (XII, 139).—§ 648: How a king should behave when
there is a general decadence of righteousness: the old story
of the discourse between Bhāradvāja and king Śatruñjaya,
i.e. Kaṇikopadeśa (b) (XII, 140).—§ 649: How a
brahman should live when there is terrible distress around.
Bhīṣma said that the Kṛta, etc. (α), are all dependent on the
king's conduct, citing the old story of the discourse between
Viśvāmitra and the Cāṇḍāla in a hamlet inhabited by Cāṇḍālas.
Towards the end of Tretā and the beginning of Dvāpara
a frightful drought occurred extending over twelve years;
the planet Bṛhaspati began to move in a retrograde course,
and Soma receded towards the south, etc. (description); the
brahmans abstained from sacrifices and recitations of the Vedas,
and no longer uttered vaṣaṭs, etc.; the very Ṛṣis, giving
up their vows, began to wander hither and thither. M.-ṛ.
Viśvāmitra, leaving his wife and son, wandered fireless and
homeless, and regardless of food, clean and unclean. One
day he came upon a hamlet, in the midst of a forest,
inhabited by cruel hunters, etc. (description of a Cāṇḍāla
hamlet). Viśvāmitra, in rage of hunger, wanted to steal
a dog's haunch (“theft is allowable in a season of distress
even for an eminent person;…in the first place one
should steal from a low person…”). He was discovered
and harshly addressed by the owner; but when the Cāṇḍāla
learned who he was he addressed him respectfully, and
dissuaded him from eating dog's meat, as the dog is less
clean than a jackal, and the haunch of a dog is much
worse than other parts of his body; “only the five kinds
of five-clawed animals are clean food for brahmans and
kṣattriyas and vaiśyas, as laid down in the scriptures”
(yathāśāstraṃ). Viśvāmitra said that it is the duty of the
brahmans to behave like Agni (as it is the duty of the
kṣattriyas to behave like Indra), that the Vedas are fire,
and that fire at times becomes a consumer of everything;
“life is better than death; if living one may acquire
virtue”; he mentioned that Agastya, when hungry, ate up
the Asura Vātāpi (“a man who is a Ṛṣi cannot do what
is sinful”). Notwithstanding the warnings of the Cāṇḍāla,
Viśvamitra took away that haunch of dog's meat into
the woods and wished to eat it with his wife, having
gratified the gods and the Pitṛs; igniting a fire according to
the Brāhma rites and cooking a caru according to the
Aindrāgneya rites, dividing the caru into due portions, he
invoked the gods, including Indra. Meanwhile Indra began to
pour rain copiously. Viśvāmitra, having completed the rites,
himself ate that meat. Afterwards he destroyed all his sins
by his penances and acquired the most wonderful success
(XII, 141).—§ 650: Yudhiṣṭhira was distressed at the
possibility of such acts of impiety being mentioned as a duty.
Bhīṣma said that kings should gather wisdom from various
sources, and not from the Vedas alone. Those who blame
the injunctions of the scriptures, etc., are hucksters in
learning and Rākṣasas among men; it has been heard
by us that the texts of morality cannot be understood
solely by discussion or by one's own intellect; Indra
has said that this is the opinion of Bṛhaspati;…
in days of old Uśanas told the Daiteyas this truth, that
scriptures are no scriptures if they cannot stand the test of
reason;…the sin of killing a person is equal to the sin of
not killing one that deserves to be killed. Indra has said
that in times of distress the great duty of a king is chastising
the wicked and protecting the good (XII, 142).—§ 651:
Yudhiṣṭhira enquired after the merits of protecting suppliants.
Bhīṣma, reminded of Śibi, etc., told the story (that purifies
the heart from every sin) that Bhārgava (i.e. Rāma, PCR.)
had recited to king Mucukunda, how a pigeon won success
(siddhi), i.e. Kapota-lubdhaka-saṃvāda (b) (XII, 143-
149).—§ 652: Requested by Yudhiṣṭhira about how
a person can be purified after having committed sin from
want of judgment, Bhīṣma related the old tale, applauded
by Ṛ., of what the brahman Indrota Śaunaka said to
Janamejaya, i.e. Indrota-Pārīkṣitīya (b) (XII, 150-
152).—§ 653: Asked by Yudhiṣṭhira if he had ever seen or
heard of any mortal restored to life after having succumbed
to death, Bhīṣma related the story of the discourse between
a vulture and a jackal as it had happened of old in the forest of
Naimiṣa, i.e. Gṛdhra-gomāyu-saṃvāda (b) (XII, 153).—
§ 654: Yudhiṣṭhira asked Bhīṣma as to how a weak king
who incurs the wrath of a powerful one should behave in the
hour of danger. Bhīṣma told the story of the discourse
between Pavana and the śālmali, who, having dared the
Wind-god, saved himself by causing his branches to be lopped
off: Pavana-śālmali-saṃvāda (b). “One should over-
look the wrongs inflicted by a person of superior strength,
and even consider them like the acts of a child, an idiot, or
one that is blind or deaf. The eighteen akṣauhiṇīs were
not equal in might to Arjuna” (XII, 154—157).—§ 655:
Covetousness is the cause of sin; it is not known in its real
nature by D., G., As., M.-U., etc. (XII, 158). Discourse
on ignorance; it has its origin in covetousness; Janaka,
etc. (α), acquired heaven in consequence of their having
repressed covetousness (XII, 159). The moral laws laid
down by M.-ṛ. are many; the highest among them all is
self-restraint; it surpasses charity and sacrifice and study
of the Vedas (XII, 160). Penance (tapas) is the root of
everything; by penance Prajāpati created the universe,
etc., and Ṛ. acquired the Vedas and acquired their
sixfold divine attributes (aiśvaryaṃ); renunciation (saṃ-
nyāsaḥ) constitutes the highest penance (XII, 161).
Discourse on Truth and its indications; it is applauded by
brahmans, Ṛ., and P.; it is yoga, it is Brahmán, sacrifice,
etc.; it has been found to weigh heavier than 1,000 horse-
sacrifices (XII, 162). Discourse on the thirteen vices that
are powerful foes of all; all these thirteen faults stained
the sons of Dhṛtarāṣṭra (XII, 163). The characteristics
of malevolent persons (XII, 164). How brahmans should
be provided for. At the end of every year one should
perform the Vaiśvānara sacrifice (iṣtiṃ Vaiśvānarīṃ).
The practice of an act laid down in an alternative is not
destructive of virtue; fearing death, V.-D., Sā., the brahmans,
and M.-ṛ. make use of the alternative instead of the
principal rule in seasons of distress. The five kinds of
falsehood that are not sinful. The three sins that cannot be
expiated. Acts that are never sinful (“amṛta, if extracted
from poison, can be quaffed”). Different kinds of expiation
for different kinds of sin (XII, 165).—§ 656: Questioned
by Nakula, Bhīṣma related Khaḍgotpattikathana (q.v.)
(XII, 166).—§ 657: When Bhīṣma became silent Yudhi-
ṣṭhira returned home. Yudhiṣṭhira's question to Vidura
and his own brothers about the three things (trivarga, i.e.
virtue, wealth, and desire). Vidura assigned precedence to
virtue. Arjuna assigned precedence to wealth (or profit).
Nakula and Sahadeva assigned the precedence to both wealth
and virtue. Bhīmasena assigns precedence to desire (“it
is from desire that Ṛ. devote themselves to penances”).
Yudhiṣṭhira applauded withdrawal from the three things,
recommending emancipation (mokṣa) (“we do not know,
however, what emancipation is”) or extinction (nirvāṇa), and
quoted Brahmán.—All of them were filled with delight and
applauded Yudhiṣṭhira, who once more addressed Bhīṣma
(XII, 167).—§ 658: Asked by Yudhiṣṭhira with whom
friendship is delightful, Bhīṣma, having also stated with whom
friendship should be avoided, related an old story that had
occurred in the country of the Mlecchas, that lies to the north,
about an ungrateful person, i.e. Kṛtaghnopākhyāna (b).
Bhīṣma's observations on ingratitude (XII, 168—173).